This story was initially printed in On Background with Mark Stenberg, a free, weekly e-newsletter that explores the important thing themes shaping the media business. You’ll be able to join it here.

Cease me when you have heard this earlier than, but it surely bears repeating: When OpenAI debuted ChatGPT in November 2022, it launched an existential downside that, even after greater than three years, has but to discover a resolution.

In brief, reply engines depend on the copious availability of high quality information to gas their responses, which they draw from content material creators, like publishers. But in answering customers’ questions with out sending these customers again to the web sites that provided the information, they starve these publishers of income, making a system that’s, fairly clearly, unsustainable. Over time, the publishers will wither, the reply engines will lose their information suppliers, and the mannequin will collapse.

This elementary paradox has risen from a priority to a disaster for the digital media business, which has seen its collective search site visitors, and its attendant income, plummet in recent times. It has spurred countermeasures from content material creators, equivalent to diversifying their site visitors sources or signing one-off offers with reply engines, however these are stays of execution, at greatest.

For the open internet to outlive, a brand new funds infrastructure must emerge that permits publishers to be compensated by AI companies to be used of their information. And to date, the early outcomes on this entrance have been uninspiring: A lot of the initiatives contain publishers proscribing internet crawlers’ entry to their content material—an effort to create shortage and, finally, enhance the worth of their archives. 

Exterior of the various technical challenges concerned in establishing such a system, a much more fundamental roadblock has to date confirmed impassable: The AI companies have little must pay. Like every good boycott, publishers’ withdrawal of entry solely works if nobody crosses the picket line, which is to say that each final web site and content material creator on the planet must hyperlink arms in unison to make such a withholding work. Naturally, that has not occurred.