When AMD launched the Radeon RX 9070 XT, it was positioned as a direct rival to Nvidia’s GeForce RTX 5070. However on the planet of graphics playing cards, real-world pricing usually tells a unique story than advertising intentions. And once we first put the 9070 XT to a head to head test in 55 video games, it wasn’t in opposition to the 5070 – it was up in opposition to the extra highly effective 5070 Ti.
Predictably, some had been upset with that call, however there was a cause: on the time, AMD’s card was priced nearer to the Ti variant, and we had been curious how it could fare in opposition to the more durable competitors. The Radeon got here in about 5% slower in efficiency, however roughly 17% cheaper primarily based on what folks had been really paying – not the producer’s recommended worth.
Now, it is time for the head-to-head matchup that a few of you had been ready for: 9070 XT vs. RTX 5070.
Since our final spherical of testing – 55 video games deep at 1440p and 4K – each AMD and Nvidia have rolled out driver updates that fine-tuned efficiency throughout a number of titles.
In the meantime, GPU costs have shifted considerably. The RTX 5070 is settling nearer to its MSRP, with playing cards out there for round $610, whereas the 5070 Ti is now hovering at $825. Surprisingly, the Radeon 9070 XT has gone in the opposite direction – presently promoting for about $860 within the US, a full 41% greater than the RTX 5070 and even pricier than the sooner 5070 Ti.
That is been a stunning flip, particularly contemplating it additionally represents a 4% premium over the 5070 Ti, regardless of being 5% slower on common and providing a weaker function set.
It is a related story across the globe, with worth gaps various by area however persistently placing the 9070 XT at a premium over the 5070. In Germany, the Radeon 9070 XT prices 745 euros, making it 11% cheaper than the 5070 Ti however nonetheless 26% costlier than the 5070.
That is an enchancment in comparison with what we see within the US, however ideally, the 9070 XT needs to be not less than 20% cheaper than the 5070 Ti and solely about 10% costlier than the 5070.
In Canada, the 9070 XT is priced at $1,100, which is 12% cheaper than the 5070 Ti, but in addition 34% greater than the RTX 5070. In the meantime, in Australia, each the 5070 and 5070 Ti can be found at native MSRP (RRP). At $1,300 AUD, the 9070 XT prices 14% lower than the 5070 Ti and 18% greater than the 5070.
In brief, meaning the 9070 XT prices 41% greater than the 5070 within the US, 34% extra in Canada, 26% extra in Germany, and 18% extra in Australia.
So, with the newest drivers in play, how a lot sooner is the 9070 XT than the RTX 5070?
We’re about to search out out with an enormous 57-game benchmark overlaying 1440p and 4K resolutions. We cannot stroll by each sport individually – as an alternative, we’ll dive into the important thing highlights and ship a complete efficiency breakdown. Let’s get began.
Check System Specs
| CPU | AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D |
| Motherboard | MSI MPG X870E Carbon WiFi (BIOS 7E49v1A23 – ReBAR enabled) |
| Reminiscence | G.Talent Trident Z5 RGB DDR5-6000 [CL30-38-38-96] |
| Graphics Playing cards | Radeon RX 9070 XT GeForce RTX 5070 Ti GeForce RTX 5070 |
| ATX Case | MSI MEG Maestro 700L PZ |
| Energy Provide | Kolink Regulator Gold ATX 3.0 1200W |
| Storage | TeamGroup T-Pressure Cardea Z44Q 4TB |
| Working System | Home windows 11 24H2 |
| Show Driver | Nvidia GeForce Game Ready 576.40 AMD Radeon Adrenalin 25.5.1 |
Benchmarks
Name of Obligation: Black Ops 6
Since our earlier testing, the efficiency of the 9070 XT has improved by 14% at 1440p and 9% at 4K in Black Ops 6, giving the Radeon GPU a major efficiency benefit over not simply the RTX 5070, but in addition the 5070 Ti. We’re seeing a 68% improve at 1440p and 70% at 4K in comparison with the 5070.
Hunt: Showdown 1896
Sadly, efficiency has solely improved by a number of frames in Hunt: Showdown 1896, and consequently, the 9070 XT is far slower than the RTX 5070 – trailing by 12% at 1440p and 18% at 4K. We’re testing utilizing the utmost in-game high quality settings at native decision.
Rocket League
The most recent GeForce driver has improved efficiency in Rocket League. The 5070 Ti is now 12% sooner than the 9070 XT, with related outcomes at 4K. In comparison with the usual 5070, the 9070 XT is 14% sooner at 1440p and 31% sooner at 4K.
Warhammer 40,000: Area Marine 2
The up to date GeForce driver has resolved efficiency points beforehand noticed in Space Marine 2, and Radeon efficiency has additionally improved. Because of this, the 9070 XT is 7% sooner than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and 10% sooner at 4K.
Assetto Corsa Competizione
Efficiency has improved for the 9070 XT in Assetto Corsa Competizione with the brand new driver. Even so, the 5070 Ti stays a lot sooner. The 9070 XT solely manages to match the 5070 at 4K whereas ending up 9% slower at 1440p.
The Final of Us Half I
In The Last of Us Part I, the 9070 XT was 24% sooner than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and 37% sooner at 4K – a powerful consequence for AMD, because the 9070 XT additionally outpaced the Ti mannequin.
Starfield
The 9070 XT is especially robust in Starfield, outperforming the 5070 Ti at each examined resolutions. It is 31% sooner than the 5070 at 1440p and 36% sooner at 4K, making this a straightforward win for AMD.
Grand Theft Auto V Enhanced
For Grand Theft Auto V Enhanced, please word we’re utilizing the utmost RT high quality preset with scaling disabled, which means all outcomes replicate native decision. For those who allow the preset with out adjusting settings, decision scaling will likely be turned on by default, growing FPS.
Right here, the 9070 XT would not carry out significantly effectively relative to the GeForce GPUs. It was 5% slower than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and solely 2% sooner at 4K.
Marvel Rivals
In Marvel Rivals, the 9070 XT sits between the 5070 and 5070 Ti, providing 14% higher efficiency than the 5070 at each 1440p and 4K. It is a stable exhibiting in comparison with the 5070, although nonetheless behind the Ti variant.
Horizon Forbidden West
The 9070 XT delivers wonderful leads to Horizon Forbidden West, comfortably beating the RTX 5070 Ti. It is 34% sooner than the 5070 at 1440p and 40% sooner at 4K, averaging 80 FPS.
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered
Oblivion Remastered additionally runs effectively on the 9070 XT, hitting 69 FPS at 1440p and beating the RTX 5070 by 30%. At 4K, it averaged 44 FPS, giving it a 38% lead.
Cyberpunk 2077
For Cyberpunk 2077, we’re utilizing the excessive preset with upscaling disabled, so outcomes replicate native decision efficiency. The 9070 XT delivered 25% greater efficiency than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and 27% greater at 4K.
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is likely one of the latest titles on this take a look at. Right here, the 9070 XT roughly matches the 5070 Ti, coming in 24% sooner than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and 21% sooner at 4K.
Monster Hunter Wilds
The 9070 XT performs effectively in Monster Hunter Wilds, providing 25% higher efficiency than the RTX 5070 at 1440p and 20% higher at 4K – clearly positioning it a tier above the equally priced RTX 5070.
57 Recreation Efficiency Abstract
1440p Common
At 1440p throughout the 57 video games examined, the 9070 XT was, on common, 17% sooner than the RTX 5070. That will be spectacular if each playing cards had been out there at MSRP, contemplating the Radeon GPU ought to value simply 9% extra.
Nevertheless, in Australia it prices 18% extra, and pricing in different main areas is usually 30 – 40% greater, which means the 9070 XT presently represents poor worth.
4K Common
The 4K outcomes are solely barely extra favorable. The 9070 XT was 21% sooner on common in comparison with the RTX 5070. Once more, in Australia it prices 18% extra, and in areas comparable to Canada, Germany, and the US, it’s priced considerably greater than the RTX 5070.
Value Per Body (versus RTX 5070)
Let’s check out how the 9070 XT compares to the RTX 5070 when it comes to value per body throughout 4 areas. In Australia, the 9070 XT finally ends up being barely worse worth than the RTX 5070 – simply by a number of p.c – so in sensible phrases, they’re practically similar in worth.
The 9070 XT does supply extra VRAM, whereas the 5070 options DLSS 4, which has an edge over FSR 4, primarily as a consequence of broader adoption.
In Germany, the 9070 XT is 9% worse in worth, and in Canada and the US, it is a full blowout, with the Radeon GPU providing 16 – 22% worse worth. In these areas, it is basically a non-starter.
Value Per Body (versus RTX 5070 Ti)
Compared with the GeForce RTX 5070 Ti, the Radeon 9070 XT turns into even much less compelling. Present pricing exhibits the 9070 XT providing simply 9% higher cost-per-frame worth in Australia, 6% in Germany, 7% in Canada, and remarkably, it is really 10% worse within the US.
Even in areas the place the 9070 XT technically provides higher worth than the 5070 Ti, the margin is within the single digits – far wanting the 20% enchancment that might be wanted to make it a clearly higher possibility.
Are GeForce homeowners actually going to modify to Radeon for lower than a ten% financial savings? We already know the reply to that. If pricing and availability proceed on this route, Radeon gross sales are going to decelerate quick.
Who Wins?
So there you will have it. Throughout a variety of video games, the 9070 XT is round 20% sooner than the RTX 5070, placing it in the next efficiency tier. That will be nice information for AMD if each GPUs had been out there at MSRP.
In that case, the Radeon 9070 XT would value about 10% extra whereas providing 20% extra efficiency. You might additionally fairly overlook the GeForce GPU’s benefits – comparable to higher upscaling assist and superior ray tracing efficiency – primarily as a result of the latter is hindered by the RTX 5070’s restricted 12GB of VRAM, which we anticipate to change into a major limitation within the coming years.
Nevertheless, as we have simply seen, AMD has not been capable of keep its MSRP – one thing we anticipated in our day-one assessment. On the time, we reported that AMD was closely subsidizing the preliminary batches of product to satisfy the marketed MSRP, whereas board companions informed us that the precise MSRP for a lot of fashions was a lot greater. This is what we said in that review:
… we’ve got some considerations about how “actual” the $600 MSRP really is. After some investigation, it seems that AMD is offering retailers with a $50 rebate to realize the $600 pricing. This strongly suggests the supposed MSRP was really $650, and AMD is briefly subsidizing fashions to hit the cheaper price level.
For instance, XFX confirmed that the 9070 XT Mercury – a mannequin featured on this assessment – won’t value $650. Actually, it will not even value $700. As an alternative, the official MSRP is $770, and as a consequence of tariffs, its on-shelf worth is anticipated to be $850 – which might be tragic if true.
From what we have gathered, it appears AMD is beginning to play Nvidia’s pricing sport. Because of this whereas some 9070 XT fashions could also be out there at $600 initially, most will possible be priced greater, and restocks at that worth could also be restricted or rare. Rather a lot will depend upon how gross sales carry out.
On the time, we predicted that tariffs would push the actual worth to round $850, primarily based on a number of pre-release sources. At present – two months after launch – the most cost effective 9070 XT is $860, which aligns carefully with what we had been informed.
Sadly for AMD, this makes issues troublesome, as Nvidia is now doing higher on the pricing entrance. As we have proven, the RTX 5070 presently provides considerably higher worth within the US, and even the Ti variant delivers a greater value per body.
In fact, this depends upon the area. In Australia, for instance, the RTX 5070 and 9070 XT supply related worth when it comes to value per body. Provided that, we might advocate the 9070 XT domestically, primarily as a result of it comes with 16GB of VRAM – which we think about the minimal for any GPU priced at or above $400. That mentioned, the RX 9070 (non-XT), which is sort of 20% cheaper, is the higher selection proper now in Australia.
Nevertheless, this does not apply to the opposite areas we analyzed. Remarkably, GeForce GPUs presently supply higher worth in Germany, Canada, and the US. In Canada, the usual RTX 5070 delivers a 20% higher value per body than the Ti mannequin, making it a viable possibility.
Nonetheless, we’re hesitant to advocate an $820 GPU with simply 12GB of VRAM – particularly for these planning to play fashionable titles at most settings, utilizing options like ray tracing and body technology.
So, after a really promising launch, supported by robust preliminary availability and aggressive pricing because of months of sponsored stock, the 9070 collection has change into a disappointing launch, not less than based on current pricing. That mentioned, it hasn’t but impacted gross sales, in keeping with the info we have been capable of acquire.
Due to the preliminary hype, the Radeon 9070 XT continues to promote effectively, domestically outperforming the RTX 5070 Ti when it comes to models bought. The true problem for AMD is provide, which has saved pricing excessive. However because it stands at present, for almost all of patrons, the GeForce RTX 5070 Ti is the higher buy, and it is the cardboard we advocate over the 9070 XT proper now.
Procuring Shortcuts:
Source link
