Automattic’s marketing problem highlighted by industry veteran

Business veteran Dave Winer highlighted a persistent sample inside Automattic Inc. on July 13, 2025, pointing to the corporate’s tendency to develop distinctive merchandise whereas failing to speak their worth to potential customers. In accordance with Winer’s blog post on Scripting News, this advertising and marketing disconnect represents a major missed alternative for the WordPress father or mother firm, significantly relating to integrations that might reshape social media landscapes.

“Automattic tends to do that, develop loopy glorious stuff after which proceed to by no means discuss it,” Winer wrote in his evaluation revealed Sunday. The commentary got here as a part of broader commentary about Automattic’s strategy to product promotion, which Winer described as basically flawed regardless of the corporate’s technical achievements.

Abstract

Who: Dave Winer, veteran blogger and expertise business observer, revealed evaluation of Automattic Inc.’s advertising and marketing strategy whereas Matt Mullenweg, Automattic CEO, acknowledged the criticism.

What: Winer uncovered Automattic’s sample of creating superior expertise, significantly the WordPress-Mastodon integration, whereas failing to successfully promote these capabilities to potential customers and rivals.

When: The evaluation was revealed on July 13, 2025, with Mullenweg’s response posted at 7:20 PM the identical day on social media platforms.

The place: The criticism appeared on Winer’s Scripting Information weblog, with responses occurring throughout social media platforms and implications affecting the broader WordPress ecosystem and digital advertising and marketing group.

Why: Winer highlighted this sample to deal with missed alternatives in social media publishing and content material distribution, significantly as conventional platforms face person migration towards decentralized options like Mastodon and Bluesky.

Winer particularly highlighted the WordPress-Mastodon connection as what he termed “the world’s finest saved secret.” This integration, which permits seamless publishing between WordPress websites and the decentralized social community Mastodon, represents a doubtlessly transformative function that has acquired minimal promotion from Automattic. The expertise permits WordPress customers to mechanically cross-post content material to Mastodon, creating alternatives for wider content material distribution throughout rising social platforms.

The technical implementation of the WordPress-Mastodon integration entails API connections that mechanically syndicate WordPress posts to Mastodon situations. This performance emerged as a part of Automattic’s broader technique to combine WordPress with different social media platforms, responding to rising curiosity in decentralized social networks following modifications at main platforms like Twitter.

Matt Mullenweg, Automattic’s CEO, acknowledged Winer’s criticism in a social media response posted at 7:20 PM on July 13, 2025. “Hah! Responsible as charged although we’re engaged on it!” Mullenweg replied, suggesting the corporate acknowledges its advertising and marketing shortcomings. His response included a directive to “Control @beeper this weekend,” indicating potential developments for the common messaging platform acquired by Automattic.

Beeper, which Automattic acquired in April 2024, represents one other instance of the corporate’s sample of creating superior expertise with restricted advertising and marketing visibility. The common chat utility helps over 10 totally different messaging networks, together with WhatsApp, Instagram, Fb Messenger, Twitter/X, Google Messages, Telegram, Sign, Matrix, Slack, Google Chat, Discord, and LinkedIn. Regardless of these complete capabilities, Beeper has maintained a comparatively low profile in mainstream advertising and marketing discussions.

The advertising and marketing problem extends past particular person merchandise to Automattic’s complete ecosystem strategy. Automattic’s ambitious plan to run Tumblr on WordPress backend demonstrates the corporate’s technical capabilities in dealing with huge migrations involving over half a billion blogs. Nonetheless, these achievements usually obtain restricted promotion in comparison with their technical significance.

Latest developments inside Automattic have highlighted the complexity of the corporate’s advertising and marketing place. Automattic: 8.4% staff cut amid escalating WordPress legal battles illustrates how authorized challenges with internet hosting suppliers have consumed vital consideration which may in any other case give attention to product promotion. The corporate applied workforce restructuring by its “Alignment Supply” program, leading to 159 worker departures amid ongoing trademark disputes.

WordPress co-founder’s criticism of WP Engine leads to legal confrontation additional demonstrates how Automattic’s management consideration has been diverted towards ecosystem governance relatively than advertising and marketing innovation. These disputes, whereas necessary for sustaining WordPress’s open-source integrity, might contribute to diminished give attention to selling technical achievements.

Winer’s evaluation attracts parallels to historic expertise promotion patterns, referencing his personal expertise with system-level scripting for Mac computer systems within the early Nineteen Nineties. He famous that firms usually hearken to rivals relatively than associates when evaluating function adoption. “Individuals do not hearken to their associates, they hearken to their rivals,” Winer noticed, suggesting this dynamic may clarify why Automattic’s improvements stay underutilized.

The WordPress-Mastodon connection particularly addresses rising demand for different social media publishing methods. As conventional platforms implement algorithm modifications and content material restrictions, the flexibility to concurrently publish to decentralized networks offers content material creators with better distribution flexibility. Nonetheless, Winer instructed that with out correct promotion, this functionality fails to drive adoption throughout competing platforms like Bluesky and Threads.

Advertising and marketing professionals inside the WordPress ecosystem have noticed comparable patterns relating to Automattic’s communication methods. WP Fusion developer wins trademark dispute with Automattic over plugin use highlights how even trademark enforcement actions obtain extra consideration than technical innovation bulletins.

Business observers observe that Automattic’s advertising and marketing challenges lengthen to broader ecosystem communication. Regardless of WordPress powering roughly 43% of internet sites globally, many customers stay unaware of superior options accessible by Automattic’s numerous platforms and integrations.

Technical documentation for the WordPress-Mastodon integration reveals subtle implementation particulars that allow automated put up syndication, customized formatting preservation, and selective content material distribution. These capabilities help advanced publishing workflows that might profit advertising and marketing professionals managing multi-platform content material methods. Nonetheless, consciousness of those options stays restricted amongst goal audiences.

Winer emphasised that efficient promotion requires understanding aggressive dynamics inside expertise adoption cycles. His evaluation instructed that particular person builders and small firms usually wrestle with self-promotion, preferring to give attention to product improvement relatively than advertising and marketing communication. This sample seems per Automattic’s historic strategy to product launches and have bulletins.

The Beeper platform exemplifies this problem, providing unified messaging capabilities that might streamline enterprise communication workflows. Options embody cross-platform message synchronization, unified notification administration, and help for each private and enterprise messaging networks. Regardless of these capabilities, Beeper maintains minimal market visibility in comparison with established messaging platforms.

Latest trademark disputes have additional difficult Automattic’s advertising and marketing surroundings. Advanced Custom Fields plugin at center of WordPress trademark dispute demonstrates how authorized actions can overshadow technical achievements, creating unfavorable consideration which will impression product promotion methods.

Group response to Winer’s observations signifies widespread recognition of Automattic’s advertising and marketing patterns. Robert Jacobi, commenting on Mullenweg’s social media response, famous pleasure about upcoming Beeper bulletins scheduled for Wednesday in New York Metropolis. His remark instructed that Automattic could also be creating extra built-in approaches to product promotion throughout its ecosystem.

The advertising and marketing implications lengthen past particular person product consciousness to broader strategic positioning inside aggressive expertise markets. Automattic’s various portfolio contains WordPress.com, WooCommerce, Tumblr, Beeper, and numerous developer instruments, creating alternatives for complete platform advertising and marketing that is still largely unexploited.

Winer’s evaluation particularly highlighted the missed alternative surrounding author empowerment by net applied sciences. He famous that writers have been “as soon as empowered by the online, and that ended with Twitter. Now it is coming again.” This commentary means that Automattic’s WordPress-Mastodon integration might handle vital market wants if correctly promoted to content material creators and publishers.

For advertising and marketing professionals, Automattic’s sample represents each a cautionary story and a possibility. Firms creating revolutionary expertise should stability technical excellence with efficient communication methods to attain market impression. Winer’s commentary that “it would not do any good if folks do not know it is there” underscores the essential significance of promoting communication in expertise adoption.

The timing of Winer’s evaluation coincides with rising curiosity in different social media platforms and decentralized publishing methods. Advertising and marketing professionals more and more search instruments that allow multi-platform content material distribution whereas sustaining management over viewers relationships. Automattic’s current capabilities might handle these wants if correctly promoted and positioned.

Wanting forward, Mullenweg’s acknowledgment of the advertising and marketing problem suggests potential modifications in Automattic’s communication strategy. The reference to imminent Beeper developments signifies the corporate could also be making ready extra coordinated product bulletins that might enhance visibility for its technical achievements.

Timeline