{"id":121405,"date":"2026-04-04T22:29:24","date_gmt":"2026-04-04T22:29:24","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/mailinvest.blog\/index.php\/2026\/04\/04\/brewdogs-pink-ipa-was-my-idea-ive-since-mastered-the-risk-and-reward-tightrope\/"},"modified":"2026-04-04T22:30:32","modified_gmt":"2026-04-04T22:30:32","slug":"brewdogs-pink-ipa-was-my-idea-ive-since-mastered-the-risk-and-reward-tightrope","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/mailinvest.blog\/index.php\/2026\/04\/04\/brewdogs-pink-ipa-was-my-idea-ive-since-mastered-the-risk-and-reward-tightrope\/","title":{"rendered":"BrewDog\u2019s Pink IPA was my idea… I\u2019ve since mastered the risk and reward tightrope"},"content":{"rendered":"

<\/a>\n<\/p>\n

Sarah Warman has had a hand in numerous explosive advertising and marketing campaigns. Bouyed by the failures as a lot because the successes, she shares the breadth of her knowledge.<\/strong><\/p>\n

For those who\u2019re studying this text, I’ve to imagine you\u2019re pondering of doing one thing a bit \u2018on the market\u2019.\u00a0<\/p>\n

\n

It makes you a bit uncomfortable, and you realize which means it’ll in all probability get individuals speaking.\u00a0<\/p>\n

It might<\/i> be well worth the threat.\u00a0<\/p>\n

Controversial concepts inherently include threat. Proper?<\/p>\n

Measuring what that threat seems like and the way it may have an effect on your model is paramount earlier than urgent the massive inexperienced button.<\/p>\n

I spent 12 years working at BrewDog, arguably one of the crucial controversy-courting manufacturers on the market. And sure, the notorious Pink IPA<\/a> was my thought. Now don\u2019t let that put you off listening to me – for I now get pleasure from lived expertise, and classes discovered the onerous approach.\u00a0<\/p>\n

Having been by means of the ringer and achieved world fame for a model with plaudits and awards, in addition to operating campaigns that warranted a Monday morning post-mortem, I\u2019m sharing with you the filters I all the time revert again to, which could stop mass fallout*.<\/p>\n

*No ensures.<\/p>\n

1. Determine if it\u2019s related<\/strong><\/h2>\n

Controversy for the sake of it’s a idiot\u2019s recreation. This filter is an important (which is why it\u2019s first. Duh.)<\/p>\n

Your controversial thought have to be related to your model. Possibly it\u2019s connected to a core theme in your sector. Maybe it\u2019s intrinsically linked to your values and what you maintain pricey as a enterprise. Possibly you\u2019ve give you a brand new product, and also you wish to launch it with an idea that feels near the bone.\u00a0<\/p>\n

If it\u2019s related, you\u2019ve cleared filter one and might progress to filter two. If it\u2019s not clearly linked to your model, and if it appears at odds with who you’re, what you say, and what individuals know you for, it is likely to be higher to park this one. However bookmark this text for subsequent time.<\/p>\n

Backside line – if it feels complicated, it\u2019s in all probability not proper.<\/p>\n

2. Solely punch up, by no means sideways or down<\/strong><\/h2>\n

Who\u2019s getting warmth out of your thought?<\/p>\n

Generally it\u2019s no person. Fantastic. Skip to tip three. If not, learn on.\u00a0<\/p>\n

If there\u2019s somebody or one thing on the heart of your idea, or an entity that can naturally really feel backlash out of your marketing campaign, make doubly positive they\u2019re not going to be worse off on account of your inventive endeavors.<\/p>\n

It\u2019s usually not cool to take goal at your friends, people who\u2019ve not chosen to be within the public eye, or manufacturers and companies of a smaller scale than yours.<\/p>\n

Greater manufacturers, celebrities, political leaders, and so on., all are typically a extra snug goal if it\u2019s related (see filter one), however in any case, retain a component of sensitivity about whether or not the goal deserves your ire. And finally, whether or not your meant viewers will agree with you.<\/p>\n

As a aspect word, it goes with out saying that sure themes ought to all the time be off limits. Something that might be construed as discrimination just isn’t acceptable. However you\u2019re a decent paid-up reader of The Drum! You\u2019re accountable; you already knew this bit.<\/p>\n

\n

Wish to go deeper? Ask The Drum<\/h4>\n


\n <\/p>\n

<\/miso-explore>\n <\/p>\n<\/div>\n

3. Determine who will hate it. (Be ready to lose them)<\/strong><\/h2>\n

If it\u2019s controversial, which means some individuals won’t prefer it. That\u2019s simply what it means.<\/p>\n

You wouldn\u2019t have gotten this far when you weren\u2019t conscious of that, however it is advisable to determine who gained\u2019t prefer it and whether or not you\u2019re keen to threat dropping them.<\/p>\n

Possibly they had been by no means your buyer or group within the first place, or possibly they\u2019re on the opposing aspect to what you\u2019re proposing.<\/p>\n

Take Bud Mild\u2019s influencer collaboration with Dylan Mulvaney. She had an enormous following, an unbelievable presence on-line, and for Bud, the chance was clear. Faucet into a brand new viewers, refresh the model and modernize who Bud Light speaks to<\/a>. What it failed to contemplate was fairly how right-leaning its core demographic was.<\/p>\n

Nearly all of Bud Mild\u2019s present clients merely didn’t vibe with this collab. Now, you may say being progressive and inclusive is extra necessary than pandering to hostile views, and in that, I would agree with you. However within the context of this text, Bud might have discovered different concepts that averted plummeting the share worth, jettisoning loyal clients en masse, and inflicting a number of execs to lose their jobs.<\/p>\n

No matter occurs, weigh up the danger and who will take offence. Are you keen to alienate them?<\/p>\n

4. Construct in your small business, seamlessly<\/strong><\/h2>\n

Positive, you ticked off \u2018is it related?\u2019 from level certainly one of this text, however the work doesn\u2019t finish there.<\/p>\n

Vacuous, empty concepts with no direct hyperlink to your model are simply memes or jokes. These should not efficient and gained\u2019t do something for you long run. Arguably, that makes it not well worth the threat.<\/p>\n

To get model worth, you want a mechanic for patrons to have interaction with the concept, or a solution to join it seamlessly to your model or enterprise. In jargon phrases, what\u2019s the CTA?<\/p>\n

A controversial advertising and marketing thought is excessive threat by its nature, so guaranteeing you maximize the returns of your risk-taking escapades means you reap absolutely the best of rewards.<\/p>\n

A latest instance of this was when On The Seaside\u2019s introduced an idea in response to Brooklyn Beckham\u2019s open letter to his household. Nationwide treasures airing their soiled laundry in public is honest recreation.<\/p>\n

<\/figure>\n

It actually divided opinion, and On The Seaside determined to dive in with a topical take – A \u2018Household Fallout Refund\u2019 also referred to as the \u2018Beckham Clause\u2019, permitting clients to get a full refund if relations turn into\u2026ahem\u2026strained, earlier than it\u2019s time for takeoff. It was controversial as a result of not everybody agreed with light-hearted jibes and company joviality within the face of familial breakdown. However On the Seaside knew its core clients would get it, and prefer it.<\/p>\n

Importantly although, this was clearly and intrinsically linked to the product. It wasn\u2019t simply an AI-generated bus cease billboard mockup (though, that was the core visible part), it was crystal clear, however nonetheless chopping near the bone.<\/p>\n

Don\u2019t skip the CTA.<\/p>\n

5. Take into account your stakeholders<\/strong><\/h2>\n

If there\u2019s an opportunity you may lose a serious buyer over an Instagram story, it’s in all probability not well worth the threat.\u00a0<\/p>\n

But when your stakeholders are tremendous cool with it? Sensible!\u00a0<\/p>\n

However even when you gained\u2019t lose them, your job just isn’t finished. There is a chance to strengthen relationships by letting them in on it simply earlier than you go reside, so that they\u2019re prepared when it occurs. Maybe they’ll activate a component inside shops, share it with their groups, interact on social media, or simply really feel part of the plans, and due to this fact belief you extra because of this. Look past the carousel, and consider what levers you may pull with stakeholders to incorporate them, and squeeze each final drop of worth out of your intelligent thought.<\/p>\n

In an analogous vein, who’re your frontline staff? You probably have crew members who reply telephones or work on store flooring, they could get clients asking questions concerning the marketing campaign. Be 100% positive you\u2019ve finished all you may to allow them to know upfront, and put together them with FAQs and signposting if they should reply questions. By no means, ever go away them out on a limb.<\/p>\n

The ultimate factor I\u2019ll say about stakeholders is to work carefully together with your wider crew to ensure all views are heard, and all potential hurdles are acknowledged. Ops, authorized, individuals and so on. Streamline exchanges to make sure they’re included, however hold it succinct. Don\u2019t miss the boat, however calculate your threat.<\/p>\n

Able to take the leap?<\/p>\n

I\u2019ve discovered these classes the onerous approach, and finally, you gained\u2019t know what response you\u2019ll get until you attempt.<\/p>\n

However contemplating threat and guaranteeing you\u2019re snug with it earlier than you unleash your thought into the world is sensible.<\/p>\n

After then, strap in, put together to sweat, and maintain on to your seats.<\/p>\n

Sarah Warman is a fractional CMO who beforehand served as a lead marketer at BrewDog.<\/i><\/p>\n

Get in touch with Sarah on LinkedIn.<\/strong><\/a><\/p>\n

Read more opinion on The Drum.<\/strong><\/a><\/p>\n<\/div>\n